Horace Engdahl pushes for Internet Control

This is our second article in Expressen. It’s a response to the Swedish Academy’s secretary Horace Engdahl, who strongly opposes decriminalizing file sharing. 13 Moderate-Party parliamentarians signed the article.

Led by Swedish-Academy secretary Horace Engdahl, a coalition of special interests is attacking our proposal to reform the laws that currently criminalize millions of Swedes. They argue that allowing file sharing would be a hard blow to tens of thousands of creative artists. However, those that signed the article are not creative artist themselves. Instead it is a group of lobbyists who join Engdahl in claiming that they represent the interests of artists.

The article writers’ clients are not artists but distributors. It is fully logical that the Publisher’s Association is skeptical to a technical development that enables writers to distribute their work without the help of publishers. The Recording Industry’s interest organization IFPI is in the same boat. Recording studios are obviously not interested in a market where they themselves are not needed.

There will always be some people whose goal is to preserve the current order. When the market changes, they get frightened and call for harsher legislation. Their interest in stopping progress must be weighed against the public’s interest in taking advantage of the opportunities that technology gives them. If politicians had met the demands from the copyright industry throughout history we would have had a considerably poorer media landscape; without VCR:s, mp3 players and online tv.

Of course the media industry needs reasonable rules to play by, but the public’s view of what is reasonable differs from the one that the Swedish Academy’s secretary expresses. Therefore the ban on file sharing has lost its legitimacy, and the law’s prospects of being successful are nonexistent.

The right to reasonable rules should apply also to Internet Service Providers, who don’t want to be an online police force. Making broadband suppliers watch what their customers download on the Internet would be like making postal services open every package. Those who defend creators’ rights should also defend everyone’s right to communicate without surveillance.

It appears to be news to Horace Engdahl and his allied file-sharing opponents that the Moderate Party values freedom of speech and freedom of information. Had they done their homework they would be aware that decriminalizing file sharing was part of our election platform. The following could be read on the Moderate-Party web site: ”Today’s harsh laws have suddenly criminalized millions of Swedes. Such laws are of course not acceptable. If the Parliament has passed a law that doesn’t work in the real world, one should not be afraid of changing the law.”

Horace Engdalh claims that some of us who want to decriminalize file sharing are only seeking attention, and that we don’t understand what we say. This is incorrect. We have researched the file-sharing issue well and take it seriously. The issue is exceptionally complicated and therefore we have opted for the only alternative that is possible if we want to avoid a society where individuals are subjected to unreasonable surveillance.

The Moderate Party is an open organization valuing free discussion as a tool for shaping better policies. Therefore we have full respect for those of our party colleagues who believe in tougher anti-piracy laws, even though we are convinced that our party must come to a more pragmatic position.

Stopping file sharing is not as simple as passing a law. For every file-sharing channel that is closed, new ones will quickly open, and soon file sharing will be anonymous. Besides, a large portion of all copying takes place outside of the file-sharing networks on the Internet. Everything from email to chat software and cell phones can be used send movies and music. How does the Swedish-Academy secretary plan to prevent this? By searching citizens on the street and making razzias in every private home?

What do writers living in control states around the world think of the Swedish-Academy secretary joining the special interests’ fight again free information flows? It’s easy to demand harsher laws, but more difficult to stand for the consequences. Is Horace Engdahl prepared to defend the control society that he has now become a proponent of?

Read more on Sigfrid in English

17 thoughts on “Horace Engdahl pushes for Internet Control

  1. Fantastic article Karl.

    A generation of people that have grown up sharing and downloading music and movies is nearing adulthood. This is a generation of people not encumbered with outdated concepts related to our heavily abused and corporate manipulated copyright system. These kids realize the full potential of the Internet and as they reach adulthood, their ideas will seep in to and meld with the political and corporate world, changing it dramatically.

    I hope Sweden is the first to attach itself to this new wave that will, inevitably, take place many years from now in other countries all over the world. Keep fighting.

  2. Pingback: Anonymous

  3. THere was once people like this Engdahl character,we called them big brother. The information age disolved them. Their organization was called CCCP (USSR). Engdahl truly doesn’t get it, try as he might to bolster his specious argument, file sharing is inevitable with the coming generation.

  4. Regardless of whether your keep the coffee maker out
    in the counter or perhaps retained away
    within the cabinet, make every effort to invest it as part of a place where it
    should be out after food splatters or perhaps in
    continued contact with hands. Drip Coffee Maker Usually Asked queries what is definitely the really
    heat for brewing coffee? about experts think that 200 levels is definitely the most effective
    temperature for brewing coffee.

    • WOWWW !! You write so beautifully. Itna saara iimagnation Loved the poem and will make sure to go throught all the other poems too. Din ban gaya )- @bubbly_ank

  5. Retournant aux lunettes de soleil de jacobs de marc parce que qui is ce que les intérêts nous aujourd’hui vous a un le site Internet vous probablement peut fournit à 50 moitié de pourcent coût, un great offre vous ne peut pas overlook because a limité in temps et aussi inventaires. par et aussi a moulé les cadres et les assemblées en plastique pour le le gain le confort mais aussi comme de le style. cannot de can de légende de mode essaie être a créé chaque à l’an
    . récemment là j’en fait aussi le carbone version is en fait dans mon advice le la plupart d’ les versions de breathtaking du même .
    COULEUR multinationale les cadres, les branches ou peut-être a teinté des lunettes, les combinaisons are innombrable et aussi la collection continue à augmenter
    chaque saison summertime.

  6. Unquestionably consider that that you stated. Your favourite
    justification seemed to be on the net the simplest
    factor to have in mind of. I say to you, I definitely get
    annoyed even as folks think about concerns that they just
    do not realize about. You controlled to hit the nail upon the top and
    outlined out the entire thing without having side-effects , other people can take a signal.

    Will probably be again to get more. Thanks

  7. Greetings from Carolina! I’m bored to tears at work
    so I decided to browse your blog on my iphone during lunch break.
    I really like the information you present here and
    can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m
    surprised at how fast your blog loaded on my phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G
    .. Anyhow, wonderful site!

  8. Simply desire to say your article is as astounding.

    The clarity on your publish is simply nice and that i can suppose
    you are an expert on this subject. Well along with your permission allow
    me to grasp your RSS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post.
    Thanks 1,000,000 and please keep up the rewarding work.

  9. I’m really loving the theme/design of your web site.
    Do you ever run into any internet browser compatibility
    issues? A handful of my blog audience have complained about
    my blog not operating correctly in Explorer but looks
    great in Chrome. Do you have any suggestions to help fix this problem?

  10. The RPG content of the game overall adds a bit of depth to the puzzles that you are trying to solve, and the tetfris like
    gamke play makes it addicting from the beginning. One need noot buy a word searches as there are endless
    possibilities and combinations available in Word Search Deluxe.
    With the rest of the people who made it an expertise, why don’t you grab a
    pencil and start playing with it.

  11. The best way to answer this question is in the form off descriptions of my gaming experience, as opposed to
    just a simple “yes” or “no”. An entire genre has sprung up around zombie gaming and this popularity has resulted in a series of different app games for smart phones revolving around zombies. Fortunately, there aree online games that you can instantly locate, play and enjoy.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s